Health

Piedmont Northside and Martin Army Earn A's, St. Francis a B and Midtown a 4th Straight C in Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades

Martin Army Community Hospital at Fort Benning, seen across its landscaped interior courtyard on the hospital's Nov. 7, 2014, ribbon-cutting day. The Army hospital earned an A in Leapfrog's fall 2026 safety grades.

Martin Army Community Hospital at Fort Benning, seen across its landscaped interior courtyard on the hospital's Nov. 7, 2014, ribbon-cutting day. The Army hospital earned an A in Leapfrog's fall 2026 safety grades. Photo: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Savannah District / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

COLUMBUS, Ga. - Columbus-area hospitals landed on three different rungs of a national patient-safety report card released this week, and the gap between them has held since early 2025. Piedmont Columbus Regional Northside and Martin Army Community Hospital at Fort Benning each earned an "A" in The Leapfrog Group's fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades, published Wednesday, Nov. 18. St. Francis-Emory Healthcare earned a "B," and Piedmont Columbus Regional Midtown received a "C" for the fourth grading round in a row, according to Leapfrog's HospitalSafetyGrade.org.

What the grades measure

The Leapfrog Group is an independent nonprofit that grades general hospitals twice a year, each spring and fall, on how well they protect patients from errors, accidents, injuries and infections. Its website says the letter grades come from expert analysis of publicly available data using up to 31 national measures of hospital safety. The same site says the grade is not meant to be the only way to judge a hospital, and tells patients never to delay care because of it.

The Chattahoochee Valley scorecard

Advertisement
HospitalCityFall 2026Spring 2026Fall 2025
Piedmont Columbus Regional NorthsideColumbusAAA
Martin Army Community HospitalFort BenningANot gradedNot graded
Wellstar West Georgia Medical CenterLaGrangeAAA
St. Francis-Emory HealthcareColumbusBBB
East Alabama Medical CenterOpelikaBCC
Piedmont Columbus Regional MidtownColumbusCCC
Jack Hughston Memorial HospitalPhenix CityGrade not assignedGrade not assignedGrade not assigned

The table uses the grades shown on each hospital's HospitalSafetyGrade.org page after the Nov. 18 update. The fall 2026 letters for Northside, Martin Army, Wellstar West Georgia and St. Francis also match the Georgia lists Patch published the same day. East Alabama Medical Center's B and Jack Hughston's status match Patch's separate Alabama list.

A two-year split inside Columbus

Northside has earned an A in every grading round shown on its Leapfrog page, going back to spring 2023. Leapfrog marks its fall 2026 grade as a "Straight A," and Georgia Watch, a consumer group that publicizes the grades, said this week that the label goes to hospitals with an A in five consecutive rounds. Georgia Watch counted seven Georgia hospitals with that status this fall.

Midtown's path has run the other way. Its Leapfrog history shows a B in both 2023 rounds, an A in spring 2024 and a B in fall 2024, followed by a C in spring 2025, fall 2025, spring 2026 and now fall 2026. On 2025 data, Midtown's MRSA infection ratio was 1.006, compared with an average hospital score of 0.656, where any number above 1 means more infections than expected given the hospital's patient load and how common MRSA is in its community.

St. Francis-Emory has climbed. Its page shows a C in all four rounds of 2023 and 2024, then a B in each of the four rounds since spring 2025. Piedmont's newsroom posted Nov. 18 releases on A grades at five other Piedmont hospitals, but none about its Columbus campuses as of Thursday.

Fort Benning and across the river

Martin Army Community Hospital, the Army's hospital at Fort Benning, returned to the grade list with an A after Leapfrog showed it as not graded in fall 2025 and spring 2026. It had earned an A in fall 2024 and spring 2025 and a B in spring 2024. Patch's Georgia list names it among the state's 20 A hospitals, alongside Northside and Wellstar West Georgia in LaGrange.

In Alabama, East Alabama Medical Center in Opelika moved up to a B after a C in every round shown on its page back to spring 2023. Patch reported that only seven Alabama hospitals earned an A this fall and that the state ranked 45th in the share of hospitals receiving one. Two Alabama hospitals, Gadsden Regional Medical Center and Medical West in Bessemer, received a D, according to Patch.

Jack Hughston Memorial Hospital in Phenix City is listed as "Grade Not Assigned," which Patch noted is not the same as a failing grade. Leapfrog said a federal court in South Florida ruled it cannot assign grades to certain hospitals that did not take part in its 2025 or 2026 hospital survey, and that it is applying the same approach nationwide while it appeals. Hughston's last letter grade on the site was a C in spring 2024.

Georgia and the nation

Georgia Watch said 74 Georgia hospitals were graded this fall and 20 earned an A, or 27%, against a national rate of 38%. The group said the number of Georgia A grades did not change from spring 2026. Nationally, Leapfrog said 900 hospitals earned an A, 774 a B, 655 a C, 35 a D and three an F.

"There's no good price for bad care," Leah Binder, Leapfrog's president and CEO, said in the group's release. Liz Coyle, Georgia Watch's executive director, said the group believes "transparency is essential to improving patient safety and holding hospitals accountable." Neither statement singled out a Columbus-area hospital.

What to watch next

Leapfrog's next round of grades is due in spring 2027, when Midtown will try to end its run of C grades and St. Francis will try to turn four straight B's into an A. Martin Army's return to the list and the outcome of Leapfrog's appeal over ungraded hospitals like Hughston are also worth tracking. Patients can look up any hospital's grade and the measures behind it at HospitalSafetyGrade.org, and Medicare's Care Compare site offers more quality data.

Source: Leapfrog Group (Nov. 18, 2026); HospitalSafetyGrade.org (Nov. 18, 2026); Patch (Nov. 18, 2026); Georgia Watch (Nov. 18, 2026)

Read next · Health Great American Smokeout Thursday: Quit, Then Get Screened

News organizations may republish this story with credit. See our guidelines.

Plan your weekend with Columbus Times

Get This Weekend in Columbus every Thursday: the best local events, free things to do and family fun, plus each evening's local news. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

By signing up you agree to get the Columbus Times email newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.

Own a Columbus business? 20,000+ page views in 30 days. Ads from $125/month. See ad options Follow Columbus Times on FacebookLocal news, events and people, in your feed every day. Follow

Comments

Be respectful. No personal attacks, hate speech, spam or anyone's private information. Every comment is reviewed before it appears. Comment rules

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Leave a comment

Replying to

Most read this week

  1. Columbus Weighs Truist Over Synovus and a Civic Center Manager
  2. Fort Benning Ceremony Calendar
  3. 4 Options for McClung Stadium, From $16 Million to $85 Million
  4. Hubert Smith III Talks Love, Dating and Life After Reality TV
  5. Free Drive-Thru Paper Shredding Comes to the Columbus City Services Center Nov. 21